Although I have used the Mini-Whip before, this is the first time I've erected it properly, and made a systematic test and comparison with my other antennas.
I decided to mount the Mini-Whip to a 21-ft telescoping fiber glass mast from Max-Gain. The mast costs a lot more than the antenna, but is extremely robust. The elements are hollow, allowing the feed line to run inside the mast. I secured the antenna with Coax-Seal at the top.
Of course, the fiber glass mast needs a support, so I basically used what was at hand.
Identical masts have been in use for two winters in the QDFA array, and I don't expect it to collapse or break.
At the bottom of the mast I made extra room for the feedline to avoid stress and potential damage.
On to the tests! Comparing a small, unidirectional active antenna with directive beverages from 225 to 500 meters long is a bit like comparing a family sedan with a racing car - and half expecting the former to win. And just so it's said: On Shortwave the Mini-Whip outperformed all my other antennas with a comfortable margin. But what about Mediumwave?

The first test array was comparing signal levels on the groundwave stations audible here. I compared the Mini-Whip with the QDFA phased array, and the 310 degrees beverage (225 meters). The stations were: 153 kHz NRK Ingøy, 399 kHz NDB "BV", 657 kHz Radio Rossii Murmansk, 675 kHz NRK Røst, 1134 kHz Radio Mayak Murmansk, 1449 kHz Radio Mayak Monchegorsk and 1521 kHz Radio Mayak Zapolyarny.
And this is how it turned out:
Frequency
|
Mini-Whip
|
QDFA
|
310
beverage
|
153
|
-80 dBm
|
-61 dBm
|
-70 dBm
|
399
|
-82 dBm
|
-60 dBm
|
-57 dBm
|
657
|
-73 dBm
|
-72 dBm
|
-56 dBm
|
675
|
-112
dBm
|
-103
dBm
|
-96 dBm
|
1134
|
-83 dBm
|
-71 dBm
|
-63 dBm
|
1449
|
-79 dBm
|
-75 dBm
|
-70 dBm
|
1521
|
-72 dBm
|
-69 dBm
|
-60 dBm
|
10-20 dB behind the 310 isn't bad at all, and almost equal levels with the QDFA at times. I did expect it to fare better on LW though, given its reputation as an excellent antenna for NDB hunting.
One important factor I have missed in this test however is that the other antennas have preamps in front, while the Mini-Whip has none (except the one in the Power Feed Unit).
Because of this, I did a quick measurement of each antenna's noise floor at current conditions. The Mini-Whip measured -112 dBm (1200 kHz, daylight), while the beverages were around -118 dBm. All measurements were done with the G33DDC Excalibur Pro.
Skywave tests have been postponed to a later weekend.